Chapter 21 - The dividend decision
Quiz
The level of dividend paid by a company is:
- Set by law
- A management decision
- A fixed proportion of profit
- A fixed proportion of free cash flow
In a world with no transaction costs or taxes, assuming managers make logical investment decisions, the level of dividend in any one year:
- should be as high as possible
- should be decided before making any investment decisions
- is really irrelevant
- should be as low as management can get away with
The traditional view of the dividend decision was that:
- Somehow £1 of dividend was worth more to an investor than £1 of value in the business
- Dividends should be limited to a fixed proportion of profit
- Dividends should be as low as possible
- Dividends should be a residual
The arbitrage proof of M&M demonstrated that:
- It was always better to pay high dividends
- It was better to pay low dividends
- Shareholders like dividends
- The level of dividend had no effect on shareholder wealth
If we accept the proof above:
- Companies will try to avoid paying dividends
- The dividend decision really becomes part of the company's financing strategy
- Dividends are entirely to do with profit
- Dividends should be linked to management rewards
The clientele effect suggests that:
- Companies should constantly monitor their dividend decisions
- Different shareholders will prefer different levels of dividend
- Companies need to contact shareholders to ask their views on dividends
- Companies should pay the highest dividends they can
In practice many companies seem to adopt a strategy of steady dividend growth. This is because:
- They believe that this sends a positive message to the stock market
- Nobody would invest in them otherwise
- It allows shareholders to budget better
- It makes their financial planning easier
If a company fails to pay a dividend in a given year:
- Its share price will go up
- Its share price will go down
- Its directors cannot take a bonus
- Its share price is likely to go down unless it can convince investors that there is a positive reason for so doing
In general it is likely that companies will benefit by:
- Increasing their dividend payouts
- Reducing their dividend payouts
- Adopting a reasonably consistent approach to dividend payouts
- Asking their investors what they want